×
  • Home
  • About
    • Firm Overview
    • Experience
    • Fraternal Law Conference
    • Conference Sponsorship
  • Our Attorneys
    • Overview
    • Timothy M. Burke
    • Sean P. Callan
    • John E. Christopher
    • Amy M. Hebbeler
    • Patrick K. Hogan
    • Micah E. Kamrass
    • Ilana L. Linder
    • Jacklyn D. Olinger
    • Jacob W. Purcell
    • Jeffrey C. Sun
  • Practice Areas
    • Overview
    • Real Estate and Housing
    • Tax
    • Employment Issues
    • Corporate Governance
    • Grant-Making
    • Litigation
    • Risk Management & Hazing
    • Fundraising & Stewardship
    • State Registration for Greek Foundations
  • Client Resources
  • Anti-Hazing
  • Contact
    • Contact Us
    • Join Our Newsletter
    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • Instagram
  • Newsletter

The health and safety of our employees, customers and communities are our top priority. Read about our response to COVID-19.

  • Home
  • About
    • Firm Overview
    • Experience
    • Fraternal Law Conference
    • Conference Sponsorship
  • Our Attorneys
    • Overview
    • Timothy M. Burke
    • Sean P. Callan
    • John E. Christopher
    • Amy M. Hebbeler
    • Patrick K. Hogan
    • Micah E. Kamrass
    • Ilana L. Linder
    • Jacklyn D. Olinger
    • Jacob W. Purcell
    • Jeffrey C. Sun
  • Practice Areas
    • Overview
    • Real Estate and Housing
    • Tax
    • Employment Issues
    • Corporate Governance
    • Grant-Making
    • Litigation
    • Risk Management & Hazing
    • Fundraising & Stewardship
    • State Registration for Greek Foundations
  • Client Resources
  • Anti-Hazing
  • Contact
    • Contact Us
    • Join Our Newsletter
    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • Instagram
513-721-5525
Fraternal Law

Fraternal Law Newsletter

Publications

Newsletter


Articles

  • HOST SCHOOLS CONTRACTUAL LIABILITY RISK TRANSFER: A RISK MANAGEMENT TIME BOMB OR FREE INSURANCE!
  • ENDOWMENT FUNDS AND THE UNIFORM PRUDENT MANAGEMENT OF INSTITUTIONAL FUNDS ACT
  • VERDICT IN PHI DELTA CASE AT MISSOURI
  • LAWSUIT FROM DEATH AT DREXEL
  • ZONING COMPLAINT AT UC-BERKELEY
  • THE LEGAL AND PROFESSIONAL CONSIDERATIONS OF SOCIAL NETWORKING – HOW FACEBOOK, TWITTER AND OTHER SOCIAL NETWORKING SITES PROVIDE OPPORTUNITY (AND RISK) FOR FRATERNAL ORGANIZATIONS

Search

Newsletter > November 2009 > "VERDICT IN PHI DELTA CASE AT MISSOURI"

VERDICT IN PHI DELTA CASE AT MISSOURI

Tim Burke, Manley Burke, tburke@manleyburke.com


Falls from high places continue to be an important risk management issue.

In October of 2002, Katie Beetz was in attendance at a party at the Phi Delta Theta Chapter house in Columbia, Missouri.  While on a cell phone, she went out a second floor fire door onto a fire escape platform and fell through the hole which provided a ladder access to the ground.  She suffered significant injuries.  Fortunately, the fall was only one story, but the injuries were still significant and the plaintiff continues to have migraine problems.

Seven years later, the trial of the suit she filed finally took place.

There had been an earlier fall through the same fire escape.  While there was a dispute over who knew about that earlier fall, a hand-made sign had been posted on the interior of the fire escape door providing some warning.  Following presentation of plaintiff’s case with 14 witnesses, the Phi Delta Theta Fraternity was dismissed as a witness.  The case against the Phi Delta Theta Club, the owner of the house, ended in the jury’s hands following the presentation of three additional witnesses.

The liability of the club appears to have been a close call.  The jury initially reported it was deadlocked.  The Judge instructed the jury to continue deliberations and ultimately they delivered a verdict finding that the Phi Delta Theta club was 56% at fault and Beetz was 44% at fault.  The jury awarded damages in the amount of $211,000.00.  As a result of liability being proportioned based on the percentage of fault, the award was reduced by the Judge to $118,160.00.

The Beetz case has at least two lessons.  First, when an incident creates knowledge of a dangerous condition, it is critical to act to address that condition so that it does not occur again.  Second, the action taken to correct the dangerous condition needs to be appropriate to the situation.  Evidently, the jury in Beetz wasn’t satisfied that taping a homemade paper sign to the door, which was sometimes up and sometimes not, was not adequate.  A more appropriate action would have been to post a professionally made clear warning on the door that contained a specific warning of the hazard.

 

JOIN OUR NEWSLETTER

Attorney Advertising. The laws governing legal advertising in the state of Ohio require the following statement in any publication of this kind: "THIS IS AN ADVERTISEMENT." This website is designed for general information only. The information presented at this site should not be construed to be formal legal advice nor the formation of a lawyer/client relationship.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Copyright © 2023 Fraternal Law Partners. All rights reserved.

Privacy Policy Disclaimer
Fraternal Law

Newsletters

Sign Up For Updates

Get the latest news from Fraternal Law Partners in your inbox.

    By submitting this form, you are consenting to receive marketing emails from: Fraternal Law Parnterns. You can revoke your consent to recieve emails at any time by using the SafeUnsubscribe® Link, found at the bottom of every email. Emails are serviced by Constant Contact.