×
  • Home
  • About
    • Firm Overview
    • Experience
    • Fraternal Law Conference
    • Conference Sponsorship
  • Our Attorneys
    • Overview
    • Timothy M. Burke
    • Sean P. Callan
    • John E. Christopher
    • Amy M. Hebbeler
    • Patrick K. Hogan
    • Micah E. Kamrass
    • Ilana L. Linder
    • Jacklyn D. Olinger
    • Jacob W. Purcell
    • Jeffrey C. Sun
  • Practice Areas
    • Overview
    • Real Estate and Housing
    • Tax
    • Employment Issues
    • Corporate Governance
    • Grant-Making
    • Litigation
    • Risk Management & Hazing
    • Fundraising & Stewardship
    • State Registration for Greek Foundations
  • Client Resources
  • Anti-Hazing
  • Contact
    • Contact Us
    • Join Our Newsletter
    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • Instagram
  • Newsletter

The health and safety of our employees, customers and communities are our top priority. Read about our response to COVID-19.

  • Home
  • About
    • Firm Overview
    • Experience
    • Fraternal Law Conference
    • Conference Sponsorship
  • Our Attorneys
    • Overview
    • Timothy M. Burke
    • Sean P. Callan
    • John E. Christopher
    • Amy M. Hebbeler
    • Patrick K. Hogan
    • Micah E. Kamrass
    • Ilana L. Linder
    • Jacklyn D. Olinger
    • Jacob W. Purcell
    • Jeffrey C. Sun
  • Practice Areas
    • Overview
    • Real Estate and Housing
    • Tax
    • Employment Issues
    • Corporate Governance
    • Grant-Making
    • Litigation
    • Risk Management & Hazing
    • Fundraising & Stewardship
    • State Registration for Greek Foundations
  • Client Resources
  • Anti-Hazing
  • Contact
    • Contact Us
    • Join Our Newsletter
    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • Instagram
513-721-5525
Fraternal Law

Fraternal Law Newsletter

Publications

Newsletter


Articles

  • Court Upholds USC’s Deferred Recruitment Even Though USC Knows It Violates Associational Rights
  • A New Supreme Court Justice: What Does It Mean for Sororities and Fraternities?
  • Indiana University Uses Student ID Cards To Track Student Movements
  • “Off-Campus” Does Not Always Mean “Off the Hook”
  • AKA National Sorority Dismissed from Hankins’ Lawsuit

Search

Newsletter > November 2020 > "“Off-Campus” Does Not Always Mean “Off the Hook”"

“Off-Campus” Does Not Always Mean “Off the Hook”

Ilana L. Linder, Fraternal Law Partners, Ilana.linder@manleyburke.com


In April 2015, Joseph Koch, a student at Kean University, was injured when he was shot by another individual while both were guests at a party at an off-campus house occupied by several members of the Sigma Theta Chi Fraternity (STC). At the time of the party and shooting, STC was suspended by Kean University and was not permitted to host social events or gatherings, and therefore was continuing to host such events at the off-campus house. It is alleged that the party “was being hosted by fraternity members at a fraternity house, and [was] understood to be a fraternity event.”1Koch filed suit against several defendants, including the assailant, Kean University, Sigma Theta Chi Fraternity, and the STC members who occupied the house.

Finding that the shooting was an unforeseeable criminal act of a third-party to the non-assailant Defendants, the trial court held that no duty could have been imposed upon the majority of the Defendants. As such, the court granted summary judgment to the University and the Fraternity.

On appeal, however, the Superior Court of New Jersey’s Appellate Division vacated the order that granted summary judgment to Sigma Theta Chi and remanded for further proceedings.

Here, the issue came down to a matter of agency: was one of the occupants of the home, a Defendant for whom summary judgment had been denied by the trial court, acting as an agent of the fraternity at the time of the shooting? Because the trial court had not considered this issue, the appellate court held it was improper to grant summary judgment to the fraternity. Importantly, if one or more of the fraternity members who lived in the house where the shooting occurred had been acting as an agent for the fraternity, and that agent had advance knowledge of the potential for a shooting to occur based on threats made by the assailant prior to the shooting, the fraternity could have potentially be held liable.

However, because Koch reached a settlement agreement at the end of October 2020 with Sigma Theta Chi, the trial court will not have to actually examine the facts and give special consideration to the agency issue. This case nonetheless serves to caution that there is a potential for national fraternities and local chapters to be deemed liable based on the actions (or inactions) of their members, even when those members are engaged in private, off-campus activities.

1Koch v. State, N. A-5570-17T4, 2020 WL 256448, *9 (N.J. Super. Ct. App. Div. Jan. 16, 2020).

JOIN OUR NEWSLETTER

Attorney Advertising. The laws governing legal advertising in the state of Ohio require the following statement in any publication of this kind: "THIS IS AN ADVERTISEMENT." This website is designed for general information only. The information presented at this site should not be construed to be formal legal advice nor the formation of a lawyer/client relationship.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Copyright © 2023 Fraternal Law Partners. All rights reserved.

Privacy Policy Disclaimer
Fraternal Law

Newsletters

Sign Up For Updates

Get the latest news from Fraternal Law Partners in your inbox.

    By submitting this form, you are consenting to receive marketing emails from: Fraternal Law Parnterns. You can revoke your consent to recieve emails at any time by using the SafeUnsubscribe® Link, found at the bottom of every email. Emails are serviced by Constant Contact.